|
Post by mccoyxyz on Jul 31, 2010 11:45:11 GMT -5
To Col Neubauer I felt absolute disgust, loathing, as he systematically larded his files with ridiculous carbon copies, all designed to show the (approaching) Americans he was such a wonderful person; meantime, offloading the horror onto Weber. Weber's exact rank is never given, (in the translation I saw anyhow), he is always just Storm Leader. This could be Unter (2nd Lt), Ober (1st Lt) or Haupt (Capt). From the context, he was almost certainly a captain. With Weber, I felt a sense of kinship, of being inside his head, seeing the world through his eyes, even to the point of predicting several of his moves. It was not until much later I understood this. The Col was a metaphor for my parents, with that SO good act at church, convincing the world (or so they thought), how wonderful they were. I was Weber, ignoring the hypocritical nonsense on high, simply following my own strategy. Col N is taken into US custody. In the final death orgy, Weber is killed by 509 using the smuggled pistol. The ending struck me as so perfect. Weber permitted to depart the lamentable planet; Col N having to hang around and face the wrath of the Americans. And years later, when I read about Thanatos, I understood that reaction in myself. For what it's worth, I reread it about four years ago, got the exact same reaction. So, how is it possible to feel such a sense of kinship with the enemy? Does that mean shared or similar experience trumps things like what side you were on?
|
|
|
Post by Miss Bothmann on Jul 31, 2010 18:03:31 GMT -5
I have a few theories on this. It could be partly because of the abuse that you suffered in this life. You identify with the "enemy" because he is still a human being, and you probably see traits of him in yourself.
Another explanation could be that you have had a past life (or lives) where you were considered the villian. Perhaps you were abusive to others (or not) and a great multitude of people saw you as a pariah. Therefore, in this lifetime, when you read this book, you identify with him with the traits that you showed in that particular past life. Also, you may not even be aware of that particular past life...you may not have even recalled it yet. This theory I speak of from experience. I recalled a past life where I was particularly cruel to someone while I got complete satisfaction out of it.
|
|
|
Post by mccoyxyz on Aug 3, 2010 9:47:09 GMT -5
Looking back on it, the scary part of it is, my relationship with Weber was totally amoral, that is no thought given to the right or wrong of the situation. It was simply a chess game, there was an enemy to deal with, that is Col N. Whatever else happened was simply a byproduct of that. I suppose that makes me a very bad person, but hey I was only ten at the time. And as for rereading it four years ago and getting the same reaction, ouch.
|
|
|
Post by Laurasia on Aug 3, 2010 17:01:29 GMT -5
Don't feel too bad McCoy....I have a tendency to empathize with the "bad guys" in movies & books myself. Sincerely, Laurasia
|
|